Egyptians Hate America, Yet Some Have Died In An Effort To Be Like Us
With the current events that have transpired in Northern Africa, I feel the need to let out my frustration with the people in Egypt. As many of you probably know, the countries of Tunisia, Libya, and Egypt have all rebelled against their established leaders. In Tunisia, president Ben Ali fled from the country and the prime minister resigned fairly recently as they conceded victory to the protesters. In Libya, many citizens have developed a rebel force to try to force Moammar Gaddafi out of power. Unfortunately, he has killed thousands of people, ordered air force strikes on his own nation, and instructed troops to shoot protesters, all in his own country. Although the excitement of the Tahrir Square uprisings in Egypt have faded from the major news networks, the sentiments from the people still bother me. Mubarek resigned as the leader after days of tumultuous riots in the center of Cairo. During the riots, the Egyptian people and other reporters from the Arab world were very critical of the United States meddling in the affairs of other nations, like Egypt. As someone who is very patriotic, I was very affected by the negative portrayal of the United States in the news. Many Egyptians were mad at the United States because they accused us of supporting Mubarek financially. And they are actually right because we have supported Mubarek financially since 1979. Every year Mubarak has received $1.3 billion in the form of military aid from the United States. And according to lists of arms sales notifications compiled by the Pentagon's Defense Security Assistance Agency, in the last decade alone, the Department of Defense has brokered over 11 billion dollars in US arms offers to Egypt and Mubarek’s regime. We also bribe Mubarek to demonstrate support for Israel in the Middle East. We do this because for the past 30 years, Egypt has not only been a crucial United States partner in the Middle East, but the country has been a linchpin in our government’s strategy for a future Israeli-Palestinian peace agreement. This bribe is taken from the 1.3 billion dollars that we paid him annually. So, I cannot defend the United States in the accusations of supporting Mubarek with money. But I can criticize the hypocrisy of the Egyptian people. Anderson Cooper and other western reporters have been attacked in Cairo because the mobs feel anger toward them because they represent America and other western countries. Also, as I mentioned earlier, the Egyptians have conveyed their contempt toward the United States because we funnel money to Mubarek. This is fine if someone wants to hate America, not everyone will agree with us and what we stand for—freedom and the protection of democracy and humanitarian rights. But, I find it extremely ironic that the people of Egypt criticize us, ridicule us, express their hatred for us, while what they did by staging protests against Mubarek was try to become more like us. Their passionate protests and the people’s dedication to the fight against Mubarek were all in an effort to be more like America. The people want to have democratic elections that are not rigged, like we have in America. The people do not want a leader who can stay in power for 40 years and therefore become very corrupt, like we have prevented against in America. So essentially what I am trying to say is, do not try to portray America so negatively if you are literally willing to die in an effort to make your country more like the United States of America.
Thomas, I see where you are coming from on this but i must disagree with much of it. To start with, a vast majority of the reporters who were attacked were attacked by Mubarek's supporters who felt that western media was being too sympathetic to the protesters. They did not like how the demonstrations were being portrayed so they tried to eliminate them from being portrayed at all by intimidating and attacking media members. Also, I find it perfectly okay for a people that does not like America to want freedom and an uncorrupted political system. Its only human nature. That would be like the Red Sox not wanted to win the world series for fear of being too much like the Yankees. I can also understand why they dislike America. Although America stands for freedom, it has a history of supporting brutal and corrupt dictators (The US gave several billion to Saddam Hussein in the 1980s). Egyptians have every right to dislike the US because the US was responsible for keeping their corrupt president in power for over forty years. Although we do not see eye to eye on this particular matter, I still found your blog post very interesting and thought provoking.
Thomas. I strongly disagree with your blog post. I agree with Jimmy but there is some I would like to add. After 9-11, President Bush gave a speech in London, in which he said that western governments should no longer support dictatorships and should support democratically elected governments. When Obama came into office, he travelled to Egypt and gave a similar speech in Cairo telling the people that Americans are not against Muslims and encouraged democracy. Despite these speeches, nothing seemed to change in the American foreign policy towards the Middle East. Therefore, can you blame the protesters for holding anti-American signs? When they say they hate America, they target American government and not the American people.
Thomas, I see where you are coming from on this but i must disagree with much of it. To start with, a vast majority of the reporters who were attacked were attacked by Mubarek's supporters who felt that western media was being too sympathetic to the protesters. They did not like how the demonstrations were being portrayed so they tried to eliminate them from being portrayed at all by intimidating and attacking media members. Also, I find it perfectly okay for a people that does not like America to want freedom and an uncorrupted political system. Its only human nature. That would be like the Red Sox not wanted to win the world series for fear of being too much like the Yankees. I can also understand why they dislike America. Although America stands for freedom, it has a history of supporting brutal and corrupt dictators (The US gave several billion to Saddam Hussein in the 1980s). Egyptians have every right to dislike the US because the US was responsible for keeping their corrupt president in power for over forty years.
ReplyDeleteAlthough we do not see eye to eye on this particular matter, I still found your blog post very interesting and thought provoking.
Thomas. I strongly disagree with your blog post. I agree with Jimmy but there is some I would like to add. After 9-11, President Bush gave a speech in London, in which he said that western governments should no longer support dictatorships and should support democratically elected governments. When Obama came into office, he travelled to Egypt and gave a similar speech in Cairo telling the people that Americans are not against Muslims and encouraged democracy. Despite these speeches, nothing seemed to change in the American foreign policy towards the Middle East. Therefore, can you blame the protesters for holding anti-American signs? When they say they hate America, they target American government and not the American people.
ReplyDelete